M31 - The Andromeda Galaxy

THE MESSIER CATALOG

In the 18th century, a French astronomer hunted the skies for comets. Instead, he mapped the universe. Charles Messier compiled a list of frustrating, fuzzy objects that were not comets, inadvertently creating the most famous catalog of deep-sky objects in astronomical history. Today, the "M" designation remains the absolute gold standard for amateur astronomers exploring the night sky.

Key Facts: The Catalog & Equipment

Total Objects

110 (40 Galaxies, 57 Clusters, 13 Nebulae)

First Catalog Entry (1758)

M1 (The Crab Nebula in Taurus)

Known Before Messier

~45 Objects (Including M31 & M42)

Messier's Favorite Refractor

100mm (4-inch) Achromatic Lens

Messier's Reflector

190mm (7.5-inch) Speculum Metal Mirror

First Edition Published

1774 (Contained exactly 45 objects)

The Comet Ferret & The Pre-Messier Era

Portrait of Charles Messier

Not The First Discoverer: It is a common misconception that Charles Messier discovered all 110 objects in his catalog. In reality, about 45 of these deep-sky wonders were already known to ancient astronomers or early telescope pioneers. For instance, the Pleiades (M45) have been known since antiquity. The Andromeda Galaxy (M31) was documented by Persian astronomer Abd al-Rahman al-Sufi as a "small cloud" in 964 AD. The Orion Nebula (M42) was first detailed by Nicolas-Claude Fabri de Peiresc in 1610, shortly after the invention of the telescope.

A Frustrating Search: Messier's true passion was finding comets. In 1758, while searching for the return of Halley's Comet from the Hôtel de Cluny in Paris, using his modest 100mm (4-inch) refracting telescope, he stumbled upon a fuzzy patch in the constellation Taurus. He patiently observed it for days, waiting for it to move against the background stars. It didn't. Realizing it was a stationary cloud, he designated it M1.

The "Do Not Look Here" List: To save himself and other comet hunters time, Messier began logging every permanent fuzzy object he found. King Louis XV famously nicknamed him the "Comet Ferret," as Messier independently discovered 13 comets. Ironically, his catalog of "annoyances" became his enduring legacy.

Evolution of the Catalog & Pierre Méchain

Three Official Editions: The catalog was not released all at once. The first version was published in 1774 in the journal of the French Academy of Sciences, featuring just 45 objects (ending with the Pleiades, M45). As Messier continued his sweeps of the night sky, he published a second supplement in 1780 extending the list to M68. The final official version published during his lifetime appeared in the Connaissance des Temps for the year 1784 (published in 1781), capping the list at M103.

The Vital Role of Pierre Méchain: While it is called the "Messier" catalog, a massive amount of the credit belongs to his young colleague and friend, Pierre Méchain. Starting around 1779, Méchain began hunting alongside Messier. He had incredibly sharp eyesight and discovered roughly 30 of the objects in the later parts of the catalog (including beautiful targets like M63, the Sunflower Galaxy, and M101, the Pinwheel Galaxy). Méchain would locate a new object, and Messier would verify its position and enter it into the official log.

20th Century Additions (M104 to M110)

If Messier's final official list ended at M103, why do modern astronomers track 110 objects? The final seven objects were added in the 20th century by astronomical historians who studied Messier's and Méchain's personal, unpublished notes. They realized the two astronomers had clearly observed these objects but never got around to publishing a fourth edition.

  • M104 (Sombrero Galaxy): Added by Camille Flammarion in 1921 after finding Messier's handwritten note in a copy of the 1781 catalog.
  • M105, M106, M107: Added in 1947 by Canadian astronomer Helen Sawyer Hogg, who found a letter from Méchain detailing his discovery of these objects.
  • M108 & M109: Added in 1953 by Owen Gingerich, based on coordinates noted by Messier when he was observing M97.
  • M110: Added in 1966 by Kenneth Glyn Jones. Messier had clearly drawn this satellite galaxy next to Andromeda (M31) in an 18th-century sketch, but never assigned it a formal number.

Messier's Mistakes and Oddities

Double Star

Messier 40 (Winnecke 4)

Messier was searching for a nebula reported by Hevelius. He found nothing but two faint stars close together. For reasons still debated by historians, he logged the double star into his catalog anyway, making M40 one of the few non-deep-sky objects on the list.

Asterism

Messier 73

Similar to M40, M73 is not a cluster or a nebula. It is simply a Y-shaped arrangement of four completely unrelated stars that happen to align from Earth's perspective. Messier noted it looked "nebulous" in his small telescope, likely due to poor optics.

The Missing Galaxy

Messier 102

M102 is the most famous error in the catalog. Pierre Méchain provided the coordinates to Messier, but later wrote a letter stating he had made a mistake and accidentally observed M101 twice. However, some modern historians argue the coordinates actually match NGC 5866 (The Spindle Galaxy).

Interactive Laboratory: 18th Century vs. Modern Day

Modern Astrophotography of M31
Messier's Drawing of M31
Visual Observation (Sketch) [ Drag to Compare ] Modern Astrophotography

The Evolution of Astronomy: Slide to compare what Charles Messier and early astronomers would have seen through the eyepiece of their small refractors (a faint, monochrome, glowing smudge, painstakingly sketched by hand) versus what modern amateur CMOS cameras can reveal today by accumulating hours of light.

William Herschel & The Birth of "Planetary Nebulae"

A Telescope Building Pioneer: While Messier cataloged objects from Paris using relatively small refractors, across the English Channel, Sir William Herschel was revolutionizing astronomy. Herschel hand-crafted massive reflecting telescopes using speculum metal mirrors, culminating in his famous "40-foot telescope" with a 48-inch mirror. This immense light-gathering power allowed him to see far deeper into the cosmos than Messier ever could.

Expanding the Map: Herschel, assisted by his brilliant sister Caroline, systematically swept the night sky. By the time he finished, he had discovered and cataloged over 2,500 new deep-sky objects—laying the foundational groundwork for what would eventually become the modern New General Catalogue (NGC).

The "Planetary Nebula" Misnomer: In 1781, Herschel discovered the planet Uranus. A few years later, while observing deep-sky objects, he noticed several small, circular, glowing clouds that looked strikingly similar to the greenish-blue disk of Uranus. Because of their planet-like appearance in his eyepiece, Herschel coined the term "planetary nebula" in the 1780s. Today, we know these objects (like the Ring Nebula, M57) have absolutely nothing to do with planets—they are the expanding shells of ionized gas ejected by dying red giant stars. However, Herschel's historical terminology is still used by astronomers worldwide today.

William Herschel and his 40-foot telescope

References & Image Credits

  • Charles Messier (Charles_Messier.jpg): A painting of the astronomer Charles Messier at age 40. Source: Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain.
  • Messier's Drawings of M31/32/110 (m31messier.jpg): Messier's drawings of the Andromeda Galaxy M31 (Andromeda Nebula at his time). Source: Seds.org.
  • A Portrait of William Herschel (William_Herschel.jpg): A Portrait of William Herschel. Source: Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain.
  • Herschel's 40-Foot Telescope (William_Herschel.jpg): Wilhelm Herschel’s 40-foot telescope, 1789. Source: Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain.